The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 161

Elections

Suing California to set aside the mail ballots of 20,000 voters it calls 'likely aliens', three weeks before the election

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Nov 14, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

On Oct. 15, 2026, the Justice Department sued California, Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County's registrar in federal court in Los Angeles, asking a judge to bar the state from counting the mail ballots of more than 20,000 registered voters whom Homeland Security's preliminary analysis flagged as likely noncitizens, until their citizenship is determined. California mails a ballot to every registered voter and began sending them on Oct. 5.

Updated Nov 14, 2026: On Nov. 6 the department voluntarily dropped the California suit, a week before a hearing on the reliability of its list. No ruling on the merits. Status unchanged (Ruled).

Earlier changes to this entry (1)
  • Updated Nov 6, 2026: On Nov. 5 a federal judge in Seattle temporarily barred the department from demanding that Washington set aside about 400 voters' ballots or threatening officials who count them. Status unchanged (Ruled).

What happened

The department says DHS compared public California voter files with federal immigration data and found more than 20,000 people who are likely noncitizens and appear to be registered, and its complaint alleges the state 'knowingly' facilitates unlawful voting by counting ballots without verifying citizenship.

On Tuesday, Oct. 13, the department sent a letter threatening to sue unless the state segregated the flagged voters' ballots within 48 hours, and dropped off a thumb drive of names at the Los Angeles County registrar's office, which said its data security rules meant it had not opened the device by the next day; Weber said the letter came with no list and that the information 'lacks both the detail and function' to investigate, and that she would not disenfranchise voters on an unsupported and likely inaccurate belief. Gov. Gavin Newsom called the suit a politically motivated attempt to suppress voters three weeks before Election Day.

In July DHS had told California that more than 190,000 registered voters 'may be' noncitizens; Weber says it refused her request for the underlying data. CNN noted the precedent from Nevada, where DHS claimed 15,903 noncitizens on the rolls in July, narrowed that to 6,218 high-confidence matches a month later, then supplied 185 names, all of whom the state says appear to be citizens.

Election law scholars quoted by CNN called the suit at best a long shot (Derek Muller of Notre Dame), guaranteed to lose and 'a press release masquerading as litigation' (Justin Levitt of Loyola Marymount), and warned of a serious risk of disenfranchisement (Rick Hasen of UCLA), since federal law does not dictate how states verify citizenship and leaves voter qualifications to the states.

Judges have dismissed about two dozen of the department's suits for state voter data (Exhibit 47), and the department's letters warning state election officials of prosecution are Exhibit 163. On Oct. 16, Common Cause asked the judge in its separate voter list maintenance case to examine whether the California action violates her Oct. 9 order vacating that federal policy. The Justice Department said its California review did not use the SAVE database and instead relied on other federal records.

Voting rights groups also sought to intervene in the California lawsuit. No judge has yet ruled that filing the California case violated the earlier order. On Oct. 19 federal prosecutors charged 28 California lawful permanent residents with election-related offenses; the charges are allegations and do not establish that the separate list of more than 20,000 flagged registrants is accurate.

On Oct. 20 California Attorney General Rob Bonta asked the court to reject the federal request to set aside the ballots, disputing the evidence and warning of potential disenfranchisement. The court has not yet been reported to decide the request.

On Oct. 20, Los Angeles election officials said an initial sample of the federal list contained a large proportion of individuals recorded as U.S.-born, raising questions about the federal matching approach; this is a sample review, not a final judicial finding about the full list. The case was reassigned on Oct. 21 to Judge David O. Carter, who in January dismissed the department's suit for California's voter data.

The department appealed to the Ninth Circuit before he ruled, saying his silence amounted to a denial; on Oct. 26 a panel dismissed that appeal 2 to 1 for lack of jurisdiction, calling the claimed emergency self-constructed (Judges Mark Bennett and Gabriel Sanchez in the majority, Judge Patrick Bumatay dissenting). At a hearing of more than three hours on Oct. 27, Carter said he intends to appoint a special master to examine how the list was compiled, noted that certification is not due until Dec. 3, told prosecutors to 'go out and indict', and said threats against state and county election workers must stop immediately; he said he would decide how the case proceeds by Oct. 28.

Los Angeles County's review of 200 names on the list found 112 canceled or inactive registrations, to which no ballot was mailed. Separately, the DNC and other Democratic groups sued in Washington on Oct. 20 to block what they call the administration's campaign to pressure states to remove voters, set ballots aside and threaten election officials.

On Oct. 26 the department sent Washington's secretary of state a similar letter asking the state to set aside ballots from more than 400 people it suspects registered without citizenship until they are confirmed eligible, saying they cast 1,500 votes in earlier elections and acknowledging that some may since have become citizens; it said another list would follow before Election Day.

Secretary of State Steve Hobbs said his office has received about 60 department subpoenas for voter information since September and will respond only to requests that follow due process.

Where it stands

On Oct. 28, 2026, Judge David O. Carter in Los Angeles rejected the department's request to make California officials set aside the ballots, saying it would violate long-standing constitutional principles on state authority over elections, and wrote that threats to charge local officials who do not comply 'must stop'.

On Oct. 30 a divided Ninth Circuit panel refused the department's emergency request, and on Nov. 2 the Supreme Court denied it in a one-line unsigned order, with no dissents noted. Separately, on Nov. 2 Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, ruling in a Privacy Act suit by the League of Women Voters and other groups, issued a preliminary injunction barring the Justice and Homeland Security departments from sending state and local election officials lists of voters they suspect are not citizens and from asking officials to set those voters' ballots aside until citizenship is proven; she said the administration's data may be unreliable, creating a risk that lawful voters would be disenfranchised.

Her order is preliminary, not final, and it still lets federal officials answer individual citizenship checks through SAVE and prosecute federal crimes. Between Oct. 21 and 24 the department also sent grand jury subpoenas to California election officials, including the Los Angeles County registrar's office (Exhibit 163).

On Nov. 5, 2026, Judge Jamal Whitehead in Seattle issued a 14-day temporary restraining order barring the Justice and Homeland Security departments from demanding that Washington election officials set aside the ballots of the roughly 400 voters on the department's Oct. 26 list, remove them from the rolls or refuse them ballots, and from threatening officials with prosecution for counting those ballots.

He found that the department had made demands rather than requests, and noted Washington's finding that the list includes people who had already shown proof of citizenship. The order still lets the department ask the state to set ballots aside and prosecute anyone who votes unlawfully.

On Nov. 6, 2026, the department voluntarily dismissed the California suit, a week before a Nov. 13 evidentiary hearing at which Judge Carter planned to examine how reliable its list was. It told the court the relief it sought was no longer available because California would by then have mixed the challenged ballots with the others. The dismissal ended the case without a ruling on the merits and is not an admission that the department's allegations were wrong. California Attorney General Rob Bonta said the department had 'thrown in the towel' after four court losses in a week.

The administration's side

Attorney General Todd Blanche said 'State-facilitated voter fraud is unacceptable in the United States of America', and First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said California officials were given the chance to remove noncitizens from the rolls and to sequester the ballots of suspected ineligible voters and refused, so the department is going to court 'to demand that the votes of American citizens not be diluted by noncitizens'.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said even one noncitizen vote cancels out a citizen's ballot. The complaint says it is not feasible to investigate tens of thousands of people before the election ends.

After Carter's ruling a department spokesperson said criminal investigation was the logical next step and that all parties agree noncitizen voting is properly handled through criminal law. In Chutkan's case the department argued that its letters to California and Washington enforced the federal ban on noncitizen voting and were not a distinct policy a court could review.

After the Washington order, Justice Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels said a temporary restraining order is not a final ruling on the merits and that the department will keep defending its authority to work with states to keep voter rolls lawful. When it dropped the California suit on Nov. 6, the department said the timing, not the merits, was the reason: by the hearing date the ballots would already be combined and could not be set aside.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/caballots/