The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 163

Elections

Warning every state's election officials that they could be prosecuted over noncitizen voters

Mixed rulingsUpdated Nov 6, 2026

Mixed rulings means: Courts have ruled both ways on parts of it.

On July 7, 2026, the Justice Department sent letters to the top election officials in all 50 states and the District of Columbia warning that they could be criminally prosecuted for aiding and abetting noncitizen voting if they knowingly keep noncitizens on the rolls or let them receive or cast ballots, and gave them five days to explain how they would comply.

Updated Nov 6, 2026: On Nov. 5 a judge in Seattle temporarily barred the department from threatening Washington election officials with prosecution for counting disputed ballots. Status unchanged (Mixed).

What happened

The letters were signed by Harmeet Dhillon, who heads the department's Civil Rights Division, and came after courts in several states had thrown out the department's lawsuits demanding unredacted voter rolls (see the entry on suing 30 states). Election officials and experts told Votebeat the letters looked more like political pressure than the start of prosecutions.

Colorado's secretary of state called them an attempt to intimidate election officials, Washington's secretary of state said the department was sliding toward threatening election administrators personally, and Maryland's election administrator described his as a letter threatening his arrest. Noncitizen voting is already a federal crime and is rare.

On July 24, Dhillon said on Fox News that the department would take a 'broken windows' approach and prosecute every case of illegal voting it finds, after New Jersey's governor said thousands of noncitizens had ended up on the state's rolls through the motor-voter system.

On Sept. 18, 2026 the department announced charges against 16 noncitizens in seven states for registering or voting, mostly in the 2022 and 2024 elections, Votebeat reported; no election official has been charged. The department's Oct. 15, 2026 lawsuit asking a judge to set aside the mail ballots of 20,000 California voters it calls likely noncitizens is Exhibit 161.

On Oct. 26 the department announced charges against 48 more noncitizens, more than half of them in California and most of them lawful permanent residents, for illegal voting, false registration or false claims of citizenship, mostly in the 2020, 2022 or 2024 elections. No election official has been charged.

Where it stands

Courts have ruled both ways, and neither ruling is a final decision. On Oct. 30, 2026, Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco, in a suit by labor and civil rights groups, barred the department from threatening state and local officials with prosecution if they count disputed ballots.

On Nov. 2 a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel sided with the department 2 to 1; within hours a larger panel voted to reconsider and that order was set aside, and on Nov. 3 the full court ruled 6 to 5 for the administration and halted Thompson's order.

Separately, between Oct. 21 and 24 the department sent grand jury subpoenas to California election officials, including three to the Los Angeles County registrar's office, seeking their correspondence with Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter about noncitizen voting and their methods for screening it. No election official has been charged.

On Nov. 5, 2026, in a separate case, Judge Jamal Whitehead in Seattle barred the department for 14 days from threatening Washington election officials with prosecution for counting the ballots of voters on its list (Exhibit 161).

The administration's side

A Justice Department spokesperson said the letters ask the states for voluntary compliance, in a timely manner, with their obligations under federal law to ensure that only citizens vote in federal elections. Dhillon says the department will prosecute every illegal vote it finds and that activists and local officials are supplying leads.

The department declined to comment on the subpoenas; a spokesperson said criminal investigative action was the logical next step after the Los Angeles judge rejected its civil request. Los Angeles County's registrar said threats and intimidation have no place in elections.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/dojletters/