The RecordExhibit 168
Re-arresting immigrants minutes after judges order them freed
Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.
Immigration agents have been taking people back into custody at the door, or soon after, when federal judges grant their habeas petitions and order them released. On Nov. 3, 2026, a federal judge in Colorado ruled that one such re-arrest meant the man had never really been freed and was an ongoing violation of his due process rights.
Updated Nov 14, 2026: At a Nov. 9 hearing the government said ICE in Colorado re-arrested at least 18 people; the acting field office director said he stopped the practice Nov. 4. Added the split among Minnesota judges. Status unchanged (Ruled).
What happened
The Guardian reported on Nov. 2, 2026, that it had found at least 20 cases nationwide in the past year of people detained again after winning release through habeas petitions, often, their lawyers say, in violation of the court's order; immigrants have filed more than 91,000 habeas petitions, by ProPublica's count. In Minnesota, MPR News reported in October that immigrants were arrested as they walked out of the Whipple Federal Building after judges ordered them freed, and seven were re-detained there before leaving, according to the Guardian.
In Louisiana, a federal judge held a senior immigration official in contempt and ordered Ibrahim Mohammed released after ICE arrested him three times following release orders. In Colorado, Judge S. Kato Crews found that Edgardo Garcia Vargas was arrested at the detention facility shortly after his court-ordered release, ordered him freed again, and barred his re-detention unless the government first proves at a bond hearing that he is dangerous or a flight risk, warning that another arrest could bring contempt proceedings.
On Nov. 4 Judge Charlotte Sweeney opened an inquiry into ICE's practice of immediately re-arresting people released on judges' orders, said that to her knowledge about 10 people had been released and rearrested in a week, and ordered the government to list everyone in Colorado re-detained right after a court-ordered release.
On Nov. 5 Judge Nina Wang questioned an ICE official about a directive from ICE headquarters to fit people released by court order with GPS monitors unless the order forbids conditions; the government's lawyer told her he could cite no Supreme Court or 10th Circuit decision allowing an agency to add restrictions to a judge's release order.
Where it stands
Ruled, in individual cases. On Nov. 3, 2026, Judge Crews ruled that re-detaining Garcia Vargas minutes after his release was an ongoing due process violation and ordered him freed; a Louisiana federal judge has held a senior immigration official in contempt over the repeated re-arrests of one man; and on Nov. 4 Judge Sweeney told the government that ICE's re-detention of a man she had ordered released violated her order.
These are rulings in individual habeas cases, not a ruling on a written nationwide policy. At a Nov. 9 hearing before Judge Sweeney, the government said ICE in Colorado had re-arrested at least 18 people. Nathan Rasper, acting director of the Denver field office since mid-October, testified that he authorized the practice from Oct. 27 after hearing that Minnesota courts had allowed it, and that he ordered it stopped on Nov. 4; Sweeney is deciding whether to begin contempt proceedings.
In Minnesota, MPR News confirmed at least eight such re-arrests. Judges Jeffrey Bryan and John Tunheim there ruled that re-arrests violated their release orders, while Judges Eric Tostrud and Jerry Blackwell declined to order re-arrested men freed again; no appeals court has weighed in. Tunheim is weighing civil contempt over a man ICE released and re-arrested twice.
The administration's side
In the Garcia Vargas case the government argued that releasing him carried out the court's order, so the case should be closed even though he was detained again. An assistant field office director for ICE in Denver told Judge Sweeney she believed ICE was empowered to re-detain someone immediately in those circumstances, and said ICE's position is that any noncitizen without legal status can be subject to added restrictions.
A Homeland Security spokesperson said a judge's release order does not shield an immigrant in the country illegally from immigration enforcement for all time. ICE and DHS did not answer MPR News's questions about the practice. Rasper testified that he believed re-arresting people after fixing paperwork errors in their original arrests did not violate court orders, and ICE said it had no comment on the proceedings.
Sources
- Newsweek (Nov. 3 Crews ruling)
- Denver Gazette (Nov. 4 Sweeney inquiry)
- Colorado Politics (Nov. 4 Sweeney hearing)
- Colorado Politics (Nov. 5 Wang hearing)
- MPR News (Whipple re-arrests)
- Latin Times (Guardian investigation)
- International Business Times Singapore (DHS statement)
- CBS Colorado (Nov. 9 hearing)
- Colorado Public Radio (Nov. 9 hearing)
- MPR News (Minnesota cases)
- MPR News (Nov. 11)
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/rearrests/